Home » Cheri Speaks, Recipes

About Freezing Pie Crusts and Pies Plus Crust Recipe

30 October 2011 6 Comments

Freezer Friendly Pie CrustImagine how impressed family and friends will be when you present a homemade pie that even has a delicious, flaky homemade crust!  You can do it with my easy food processor pie dough recipe and with your freezer’s help, all the work will be done ahead of time.

Pie crusts freeze exceptionally well in their unbaked state.  You can either roll out the dough and form it into a crust and freeze crust and pie pan together.  Alternately, freeze disks of dough you can thaw and roll out later.  Either way works fine.

Some pies freeze well in their baked form.  My Dulce de Leche Pumpkin Pie recipe is a good example.  Other pies like those that are custard based get too watery — you’re better off preparing the crust ahead of time, then filling closer to serving time (although you can still prepare in advance and keep in the fridge).

Fruit pies are a toss up.  Some people like to freeze unbaked fruit pie then bake the frozen pie up later.  In my opinion, the crust gets too soggy doing this.  For fruit pies I prefer to freeze pie crust and fruit filling separately (find a great freezer friendly apple pie filling in my book, The Complete Idiot’s Guide to Easy Freezer Meals, 2011, Alpha Books).  When I want a pie all I need to do is our thawed fruit filling into a frozen pie crust and bake.  Perfect pie with flaky, not soggy, crust.

Cheri’s Easy Food Processor Sweet Pie Crust

Although both my parents made terrific pies, they never taught me to cook.  I learned how to make a good pie crust from my ex Mother-in-Law, a lovely woman named Louise Tegge.  Besides being the best part of my short youthful marriage and one of the kindest most unselfish people I ever met, my mother-in-law was a master baker.  And while she didn’t do it professionally, it was her true passion.  Each day she would turn out a new masterpiece.

Early in my cooking career I used her pie crust recipe with great success.  Louise’s pies were very flaky, being made with 100% shortening.  I’ve since modified her recipe to use some butter.  The combination gives the crust a better flavor while still retaining its flakiness.  I’ve added sugar to it as well, when making sweet pies (if you’re making a savory pie, just leave out the sugar entirely).  Lastly, I altered the method of making the dough to use the food processor, which makes it super quick and easy.  Now Louise might caution against doing that, because truly the worst enemy of a flaky crust is over mixing or over handling it, but stay with me here and I will teach you it can be done!

Whenever I get the food processor out to make crusts, I always make at least 4 or 5, even if I don’t need them immediately.  It’s just so quick and easy to do so when you have the processor and the ingredients out, that it makes sense.  Then next time you want to make a pie, the hard part is done!

(double recipe for a double crust pie)

For a Regular  8 or 9-inch Pie or 4 (4 1/2-inch) Mini Pies

5 tablespoons unsalted butter
5 tablespoons vegetable shortening
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 1/3 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons sugar
5 to 6 tablespoons ice water

For a Deep Dish 8 or 9-inch Pie

6 tablespoons unsalted butter
6 tablespoons vegetable shortening
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 2/3 cup all-purpose flour
1/2 teaspoon salt
2 tablespoons sugar
6 to 7 tablespoons ice water

Easy Food Porcessor Pie Crusts -- Freezer FriendlyFirst cut up the butter and shortening into small chunks and place it in the freezer for at least 15 minutes — the colder the better.

Whirl flour,  salt, and sugar in the food processor to blend.  Add cold butter and pulse just until well incorporated — the mixture will resemble coarse crumbs (see photo, right).  Remove mixture from food processor and place in a large bowl.  Add ice water and mix with clean hands just until it holds together — mixture should be a little wet.  Pat dough into a disk, wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 20 minutes before rolling (or if you plan on freezing the dough in disks to be rolled out later, you can do so now).

To Roll Out Pie Crusts

The rule of thumb to handle the dough as little as possible for a flaky crust still applies.  The best way I’ve found to do this is to roll the dough between 2 layers or plastic wrap or waxed paper.  This method also makes it easy to transfer the dough into the pie plate.

Remove your disk of dough from the refrigerator and open up the plastic wrap.  Lightly sprinkle top of dough and plastic wrap with flour.  Cover with another piece of plastic or waxed paper.

Pie Crust between plastic wrap

Use a rolling pin to roll dough into a circle about an inch larger all the way around than your pie plate.  Remove top layer of wrap and center pie plate, upside down, on dough.

Inverted Pie Pan on Dough
Pick up bottom wrap and flip the whole thing over.  Remove wrap and center dough in pie plate.

Flipping Dough Into Pie Plate

Use fingers to make a nice edge on pie by evening out the edges then use thumb and index finger of one hand to pinch crust around the index finger of the other hand, to make a scalloped edge.  Freeze crust until ready to use. (see photo top of this post)

The Easy Way to Roll  Mini Pies!

One regular pie crust recipe above will make 4 small (4 1/2-inch) mini pies .  I recently discovered the easiest way ever to roll these.  You don’t even need a rolling pin, but rather a small tortilla press, found in Mexican markets and used for making, tortillas.  This little gadget also works exceptionally well for making mini pie crusts.  Place dough between a sheet of plastic wrap on the tortilla press.

Making Mini Pies in a Tortilla Press

Press dough to get a perfectly sized mini pie circle of dough.

Making Mini ies with a Torilla Press

Place in pie crust, pinch the edges and freeze!

Making mini Pie Crusts



List Price: $16.95 USD
New From: $8.59 In Stock
Used from: $6.95 In Stock
Release date April 5, 2011.

6 Comments »

  • Shelby said:

    I’m not much of a pie maker…and I’m really lazy about making pie crusts. I’m not sure why – but you may have inspired me to make my own and have it in the freezer for our return from our cruise (which is right before Christmas!) that pumpkin pie you will be posting sounds delish!

  • Cheri
    Cheri (author) said:

    They aren’t that hard Shelby and they taste so much better than store bought refrigerated or frozen pie crusts — far more tender and flaky. With your schedule you’ll need to prepare lots in advance. Use the freezer! You can prepare most of the holiday meal, save the big protein entree, in advance.

    PS it doesn’t get any easier than the mini pie crusts made with the tortilla press (which is also great for tortillas, if you have a Mexican market nearby you can pick up bags of corn masa that just needs to be pressed and heated in a skillet — nothing like fresh hot tortillas!).

  • Melanie said:

    What a great idea — using a tortilla maker to make mini pie crusts! I’ve been making my own tortillas for a while and loving them, but I never thought to use the press for a pie crust. Duh! I just made mini chicken pot pies the other day and swore I never would again (I do that every time I make them, LOL). Wish I’d known about this simple idea then, but I will certainly try it next time around.

    After reading your idea, Cheri, I looked around online to see if others were making little pie crusts this way. A few were, and some people were also using the press to make wonton wrappers, dumpling rounds, even pasta. My head is spinning with the possibilities and I can’t wait to try it out. Thanks!

  • Cheri
    Cheri (author) said:

    Just started making my own tortillas (cause the Mexican market nearby sells masa, so all you have to do is press and cook). The press was on the counter when I started making pies and it just seemed like a natural — and it was. I thought about using it for other things too but haven’t gotten that far yet, but for mini pies, it’s the easiest way ever.

  • sue said:

    i loved your idea for making pie crust and will give ita try I am making the 4 inch for the fair and do have another question if you could answer it for me. The pie I am making takes 45 minutes for a 9 inch how would I adjust the time for a 4 in The pie is the Southern Chess Pie thank you

  • Cheri
    Cheri (author) said:

    Thanks Sue! I am not where I can test to tell you the exact difference in time right now. Start with half the time for a large pie and look at the pie to evaluate if it is set. If not watch carefully after that and check every couple of minutes until you get the timing down. Best of luck at the fair! Chess pie, yum!

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.